Melvor Idle 2 Review: A Smart Idle RPG, Still Under Construction
Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure enters Early Access with 29 skills, real quests, full-speed offline progress and no microtransactions for under EUR 15. It is unfinished and English-only, but the foundation is strong. Early Access score: 7/10.
Luka Perić
Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Melvor Idle 2: A RuneScape Adventure entered Steam Early Access today, 17 November, on Windows, macOS and Linux. It is developed by Games by Malcs and published by Jagex, and it follows a first game that the two companies say sold over a million copies. The price is EUR 14.49, with a 10% launch discount to EUR 13.04 until 24 November, and the developer says it will not go up at 1.0.
One thing up front: this is a launch-day Early Access verdict, based on what is in the build and on the store page today. I will revisit the score when the game is finished.
What it is
RuneScape with the walking removed. There is no world to run around in; you pick a skill, set an action going and watch numbers climb. In the first game, woodcutting fed firemaking and fletching and mining fed smithing; the sequel keeps that interlocking structure, with skills such as woodcutting, smithing, cooking, farming, combat and magic. It is a single-player idle RPG, and its trick is that every bar you fill makes other bars more interesting.
What is new
The sequel brings 29 skills, five of them new, with a level cap of 120. Combat still splits into melee, ranged and magic, with dungeons and bosses on top. The additions that matter most to me are structural:
- A proper quest system with boss fights and some history of the world, so there is finally a reason to do things in a certain order. - Mastery Guilds covering every skill, combat included. - Game modes, a first for the series. - A day/night cycle and weather, plus an in-game Codex, an event log and live rate tracking for whatever you are doing.
The quality-of-life list is just as long: cloud saves, a friends list, achievements and a built-in mod manager.
The good
Offline progression runs at the same speed as active play. That one line is the reason I respect this series: it does not punish you for closing the game, and it does not sell you a way around a timer. There are no microtransactions at all. In a genre where most competitors are free-to-play machines built to wear you down, a flat EUR 14.49 with nothing else to buy except a EUR 4.89 soundtrack is the honest way to do it.
It also runs on anything. The minimum spec asks for 1-2 GB of RAM and integrated graphics, so an old office laptop is plenty.
The bad
It is not finished, and the developer says so. The Early Access plan is 12 to 18 months, and some skills, combat content and quality-of-life features are still to come. If you hate reaching the edge of a game and waiting for a patch, hold off.
It is English-only, with no other interface languages listed. And it is PC-only for now, which stings for a game whose natural home is a phone on the sofa.
Finally, the obvious: an idle game is a spreadsheet with nice art. If you have never felt the pull of a number going up, 29 skills will not convert you.
Who it's for
RuneScape veterans who miss the grind but not the hours, fans of the first Melvor, and anyone who wants a second-monitor game that respects their time and wallet.
Verdict
A fair price, a clean business model and smart structural upgrades over the original. It loses points only for being unfinished and for the missing languages. Worth buying now if you are happy to grow along with it.
Score: 7/10 (Early Access)
Image: Shixart1985 / CC BY 2.0, source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Dual_monitor_setup_in_a_gaming_room_with_keyboard_and_mouse_in_focus.jpg



