stadiongaming.eu

Sony won the £2bn PS Store case - will digital games get any cheaper?

A UK tribunal has thrown out the class action over PlayStation Store prices. Nothing changes at the checkout, but one line in the reasoning matters to anyone who still buys discs.

Jakov Mikelić

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Sony won the £2bn PS Store case - will digital games get any cheaper?

Short answer: no. If you were hoping a court would do what PlayStation Store sales rarely manage and push digital prices down, yesterday's ruling in London was the wrong place to look.

On 17 November the UK's Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed, in full, the class action brought by Alex Neill on behalf of roughly 12.2 million British PlayStation users. The claim covered digital purchases made between August 2016 and February 2026 and, by the time it reached trial, was asking for about £1.49 billion in damages - close to £2 billion with interest. The argument was simple: once you own a PlayStation there's only one shop for digital games, Sony takes a 30% commission on what's sold in it, and prices would've been around 20% lower with real competition.

The tribunal didn't buy any of it. Going by the summaries from The Game Business and Brick Court Chambers (whose barristers acted for Sony), the judges found that PlayStation competes in a wider market with Xbox and Nintendo - The Game Business adds PC to that list - that Sony wasn't shown to be dominant, that the 20% figure wasn't proven, and that the company's returns across the whole PlayStation business weren't shown to be excessive. Forcing third-party stores onto the console, they added, would raise security questions nobody had resolved.

The line I'd underline

One piece of the reasoning matters more to players in our region than all the rest: physical games count as a real substitute for digital ones. In plain terms, you aren't trapped, because you can still buy the disc. The Game Business notes the tribunal attached a caveat to that - "at least for now".

That's some caveat. The disc is exactly how plenty of us keep this hobby affordable: buy it used, lend it to a friend, sell it when you're done, order from whichever EU shop is cheapest that week. A legal win that leans on that option existing is on a timer: Sony announced on the PlayStation Blog in July that new PlayStation games will no longer be released on disc from January 2028. Games already out on disc, and those that arrive before that date, aren't affected, as Game Developer reported at the time.

The Dutch consumer foundation suing Sony over the same store, Stichting Massaschade & Consument, has argued that the end of discs proves its point - no discs means no second-hand market and no alternative to the PlayStation Store - as PC Gamer and Notebookcheck reported in July. Its case, like similar ones in Portugal and Australia, is at an earlier stage, according to The Game Business. A UK judgment doesn't bind courts elsewhere, but I'd be surprised if Sony's lawyers didn't bring it along.

So what do you actually do with this? Nothing changes at the checkout, and nobody outside the UK was ever going to see money from this case - it only concerned UK buyers. The takeaway is the boring one: for as long as a game has a disc version, that's the only price competition it has. The used and back-catalogue market doesn't vanish in 2028 - everything released on disc before then stays out there to be bought, lent and resold. What ends is new releases on disc. If you're choosing between a PS5 with a drive and one without, the drive is the very thing a tribunal just pointed to as your way out. I'd keep it.

Image: Xephuwu / CC BY-SA 4.0, source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:KontrolerDualSense.jpg

Read next